A recent joint investigation by CBS News and KFF Health News has raised alarms about a troubling trend in the dental industry: the removal of healthy, treatable teeth in favor of costly dental implants, often driven by financial incentives rather than medical necessity. The report highlights the dangers of this practice, shedding light on patients, like Becky Carroll, who have suffered from botched dental implant surgeries. The American Association of Endodontists (AAE) has responded, warning against the unethical practice and urging patients to seek second opinions before agreeing to irreversible procedures.
Ethical Violations and Patient Risks
The AAE strongly criticized the practice, emphasizing that dental practitioners who promote unnecessary extractions for implants betray their patients’ trust and violate ethical standards. The AAE stressed the importance of providing patients with comprehensive information about all treatment options, especially those that preserve natural teeth. Preserving natural teeth is seen as the best foundation for long-term oral health. “We encourage all dental practitioners to remember that their responsibility is to their patients’ health above all else,” the AAE stated.
Removing healthy teeth for implants can significantly affect a patient’s quality of life, yet many patients are not fully informed about the risks and consequences. Periodontist and prosthodontist Luiz Gonzaga from the University of Florida pointed out, “You don’t go to the hospital and ask to have your finger amputated just because it hurts. So why would a dentist remove a tooth for something treatable like a root canal?”
The Dangers of Implants and Financial Incentives
Dental implants can be costly, with single implants typically costing thousands of dollars, and full-arch implants running into the tens of thousands. In many cases, dental insurance doesn’t cover these procedures, leading clinics to partner with credit companies to offer patient loans. Yet, while implant sales have grown by over 6% annually since 2010, the risks associated with implants are significant. If implants fail, patients may not have enough jawbone for another set, potentially requiring implants that anchor into cheekbones. There is also a heightened risk of complications like peri-implantitis (inflammation around the implant), and once natural teeth are extracted, future treatment options are limited.
The financial incentive to promote implants is stark: private equity firms are increasingly purchasing large dental chains. In recent years, firms like Aspen Dental and Affordable Care have acquired major implant providers for billions of dollars. The rapid expansion of private equity interest in the dental space raises concerns about the prioritization of profits over patient care. According to PitchBook, Aspen Dental bought ClearChoice for $1.1 billion in 2020, and the Abu Dhabi government’s private equity wing purchased Dental Care Alliance for $1.1 billion in 2022.
The American Dental Association (ADA) reported that dental practices owned by private equity firms increased ninefold from 2011 to 2021. This surge in ownership correlates with an increased focus on implant procedures, which can be highly profitable.
Untrained Dentists and Patient Safety
Lawsuits across the country have accused implant clinics of unnecessarily extracting teeth, leading to misaligned implants and even patients losing the ability to chew properly. Edwin Zinman, a San Francisco dental malpractice attorney, suggests that this trend is driven by the pursuit of profit: “They’ve sold a lot of implants, some unnecessarily, and often done negligently,” he said. “It’s for five simple letters: M-O-N-E-Y.”
The investigation also found that more than 70% of clinic websites owned by private equity firms listed only general dentists and not specialized implant professionals. This raises alarms about the safety of patients receiving implant surgeries from practitioners without specialized training. Dentists performing implants must have more formal training, as implant surgeries are more complex and carry significant risks.
The Importance of Second Opinions
For patients considering dental implants, the experts strongly recommend seeking second opinions if implants are suggested as the first line of treatment. This is critical to ensure that the suggested treatment is truly necessary and that the risks are fully understood. The priority should always be to preserve natural teeth when possible and to educate patients about all available treatment options. Dentists must adhere to ethical principles, such as nonmaleficence (do no harm) and beneficence (act in the best interest of the patient), to protect long-term oral health.
In conclusion, the growing trend of removing healthy teeth for dental implants raises significant ethical, health, and safety concerns. Patients must be proactive in seeking second opinions and ensure that they are receiving care from well-trained professionals who prioritize their health over financial gain.
Related topics:
