Teeth whitening has become a popular way for people to enhance their smiles. Two common at-home options are whitening strips and gels. Both aim to remove stains and lighten the color of teeth, but they have different characteristics that can influence which one is better for an individual.
Whitening strips are thin, flexible pieces of plastic or a similar material coated with a layer of whitening gel. They are pre-cut to fit the shape of the teeth and are easy to apply. On the other hand, whitening gels usually come in syringes or small containers. They are applied using trays that are either custom-made to fit the teeth or are one-size-fits-all disposable trays.
Active Ingredients
Both whitening strips and gels typically contain bleaching agents, most commonly hydrogen peroxide or its derivative, carbamide peroxide. The concentration of these agents can vary. In general, whitening strips often have a lower concentration of the bleaching agent compared to some gels. For example, many over-the-counter strips have around 6% to 10% hydrogen peroxide or the equivalent in carbamide peroxide. Gels, especially those used in professional at-home kits, can have concentrations up to 20% or more.
The concentration matters because it affects how quickly and effectively the teeth are whitened. Higher concentrations can potentially lead to faster results, but also come with a greater risk of side effects like tooth sensitivity and gum irritation.
Ease of Use
Whitening strips are extremely convenient when it comes to application. They are ready to use right out of the package. You simply peel off the backing and stick the strip onto your teeth, pressing it firmly to ensure good contact. The process takes only a few minutes. Most people can apply the strips without any special assistance.
Gels, on the other hand, require a bit more preparation. If you have custom trays, you need to clean and dry them before applying the gel. Dispensing the right amount of gel into the trays can also be a bit tricky. With disposable trays, fitting them properly on the teeth can sometimes be a challenge. Overall, applying gels takes a bit more time and effort compared to strips.
Comfort and Fit
Whitening strips are designed to conform closely to the shape of the teeth. However, they can sometimes feel a bit strange in the mouth, especially at first. Some people find the strips can make it difficult to talk or smile freely while they are on. Also, if the strips don’t fit perfectly, they can slide around, which may reduce their effectiveness.
Gels, when used with custom trays, generally provide a better fit. The trays are molded to the exact shape of your teeth, so the gel is evenly distributed and stays in place. This can make for a more comfortable experience as there is less chance of the gel dripping or moving around. Disposable trays may not fit as well, and if they are too loose, the gel can come into contact with the gums more easily, increasing the risk of irritation.
Whitening Effectiveness
In terms of how well they whiten teeth, both strips and gels can be effective. Strips are great for removing surface stains caused by things like coffee, tea, and cigarettes. They work gradually over a period of days or weeks. With regular use as directed, most people can expect to see a few shades of whitening.
Gels, especially those with higher concentrations, can sometimes provide more dramatic results in a shorter time. The gel can penetrate deeper into the tooth structure in some cases, which is beneficial for treating more stubborn or intrinsic stains. But this also depends on the individual’s teeth and the type of staining. For mild to moderate staining, strips may be sufficient, while gels might be better for more severe cases.
Tooth Sensitivity and Side Effects
Tooth sensitivity is a common side effect of both whitening strips and gels. Since strips have a lower concentration of the bleaching agent, the risk of sensitivity is often considered to be a bit lower. However, if used too frequently or for too long, they can still cause discomfort.
Gels, particularly those with higher concentrations, are more likely to cause sensitivity. The longer the gel is in contact with the teeth, the more it can irritate the nerve endings inside the teeth. Gum irritation is also a concern with gels, especially if the trays don’t fit properly and the gel leaks onto the gums. Strips can sometimes cause gum irritation if they are not positioned correctly, but it is generally less common than with gels.
Cost
When it comes to cost, whitening strips are often more affordable, especially the over-the-counter varieties. A box of strips can be found for relatively little money, making them accessible to a wide range of budgets.
Gels, especially custom-made professional kits, can be more expensive. The cost includes the trays, which can be costly to produce if they are custom-molded. Even some of the higher-end over-the-counter gel kits can be pricier than strips due to the packaging and the higher concentration of the bleaching agent.
Duration of Results
Both strips and gels can provide long-lasting results if proper oral hygiene is maintained. Strips may need to be reapplied periodically, say every few months, to keep the teeth looking white. This is because new stains can form over time from food, drinks, and other factors.
Gels, especially when used as part of a professional treatment plan, can offer results that last a bit longer. But again, it depends on the individual’s lifestyle and oral care habits. If someone continues to consume a lot of staining substances, the effects of either strips or gels will fade more quickly.
Conclusion
Deciding whether whitening strips or gels are better depends on several factors. If you’re looking for an easy, affordable, and convenient option for mild to moderate staining with a lower risk of side effects, whitening strips might be the way to go.
On the other hand, if you have more stubborn stains, are willing to invest more time and money, and can tolerate a higher risk of sensitivity, then whitening gels, especially those used with custom trays, could be a better choice.
It’s always a good idea to consult with a dentist before starting any teeth whitening regimen. They can assess your teeth and gums, recommend the most suitable option, and provide guidance on how to use the product safely and effectively to achieve the best possible results for your smile.
Related topics:
How Long After Teeth Whitening Gel Can I Eat Normally?
What is Whitening Toothpaste Safe?
