Dental insurance is an essential tool for managing oral health care costs, covering procedures such as cleanings, fillings, extractions, and even major treatments like crowns or root canals. However, the coverage provided by a single dental insurance plan may not always be sufficient, especially for individuals with extensive dental needs or those seeking to minimize out-of-pocket expenses. This raises an important question: Are you allowed to have two dental insurances? The answer is yes, but navigating the complexities of dual dental insurance requires a clear understanding of how coordination of benefits works, the advantages and disadvantages of having two plans, and the steps to maximize coverage. This article provides a detailed and professional analysis of having two dental insurances, offering insights for individuals considering this option.
Understanding Dual Dental Insurance
Having two dental insurance plans means that an individual is covered under two separate policies, typically through different providers. This is often referred to as “coordination of benefits” (COB), a process that determines how the two plans work together to cover dental expenses. Dual dental insurance is most common in situations where an individual is covered under their own plan and also under a spouse’s or parent’s plan. For example:
- A married individual may have their own employer-sponsored dental insurance and also be covered under their spouse’s plan.
- A young adult may be covered under their parent’s dental insurance while also having their own plan through an employer.
While having two dental insurances is allowed, it is important to understand how the two plans interact to avoid confusion and ensure maximum benefits.
How Coordination of Benefits Works
Coordination of benefits (COB) is the process used by insurance companies to determine which plan is the primary payer and which is the secondary payer when a patient has dual coverage. The primary plan pays its share of the costs first, and the secondary plan may cover some or all of the remaining expenses, depending on its rules. Here’s how COB typically works:
Primary Plan: The primary plan is the first to pay for dental services. This is usually determined by specific rules, such as:
The plan that covers the individual as an employee is primary over the plan that covers them as a dependent.
For children with dual coverage, the “birthday rule” often applies: The plan of the parent whose birthday falls earlier in the year is primary.
Secondary Plan: The secondary plan pays after the primary plan has processed the claim. It may cover some or all of the remaining costs, depending on its coordination of benefits rules. However, the combined payments from both plans cannot exceed 100% of the total cost of the procedure.
Claim Submission: When a patient has two dental insurances, they must submit claims to both plans. The dental office typically handles this process, but the patient should ensure that both plans are informed of the dual coverage.
Advantages of Having Two Dental Insurances
There are several potential benefits to having two dental insurance plans:
Reduced Out-of-Pocket Costs: Dual coverage can significantly reduce or even eliminate out-of-pocket expenses for dental procedures. For example, if the primary plan covers 80% of a filling and the secondary plan covers the remaining 20%, the patient may pay nothing.
Broader Coverage: Two plans may provide coverage for services that one plan does not fully cover. For instance, one plan may have a higher annual maximum, while the other may offer better coverage for orthodontic treatments.
Flexibility in Choosing Providers: Having two plans may allow patients to choose from a larger network of dentists and specialists, increasing access to care.
Protection Against Gaps in Coverage: If one plan has limitations or exclusions, the other plan may fill in the gaps, ensuring comprehensive coverage.
Disadvantages of Having Two Dental Insurances
While dual dental insurance can be beneficial, there are also potential drawbacks:
Complexity: Managing two insurance plans can be complicated, especially when it comes to understanding coordination of benefits, submitting claims, and resolving disputes between insurers.
Limited Additional Benefits: The secondary plan may not always provide additional benefits, as its payments are often limited to the remaining balance after the primary plan has paid. In some cases, the secondary plan may not pay anything if the primary plan already covers 100% of the cost.
Higher Premiums: Maintaining two dental insurance plans means paying premiums for both, which may not be cost-effective if the additional coverage does not significantly reduce out-of-pocket expenses.
Administrative Hassles: Submitting claims to two insurers and coordinating benefits can be time-consuming and may require frequent follow-ups to ensure timely payments.
Steps to Maximize Dual Dental Insurance Coverage
For individuals considering or already enrolled in two dental insurance plans, the following steps can help maximize benefits and minimize complications:
Understand Both Plans: Carefully review the details of both insurance plans, including coverage limits, deductibles, annual maximums, and coordination of benefits rules. This will help you understand how the two plans work together.
Inform Your Dentist: Notify your dentist or dental office that you have dual coverage. Provide them with the necessary information for both plans to ensure they can submit claims correctly.
Submit Claims Properly: Ensure that claims are submitted to the primary plan first and then to the secondary plan. Most dental offices handle this process, but it’s important to confirm that both insurers are billed appropriately.
Track Payments: Keep track of payments from both insurers to ensure that the combined coverage does not exceed 100% of the total cost. If there are discrepancies, contact both insurers to resolve the issue.
Evaluate Cost-Effectiveness: Compare the premiums and benefits of both plans to determine whether maintaining dual coverage is cost-effective. If the additional coverage does not significantly reduce out-of-pocket expenses, it may not be worth the extra cost.
Consult Your HR Department or Insurance Provider: If you have questions about coordination of benefits or how your plans interact, consult your HR department (if the plan is employer-sponsored) or contact the insurance providers directly for clarification.
Case Study: Dual Dental Insurance in Practice
To illustrate how dual dental insurance works, consider the following example:
Patient A is covered under their own employer-sponsored dental plan (Plan 1) and their spouse’s dental plan (Plan 2). Plan 1 has an annual maximum of 1,5002,000 and covers 50% of basic services.
Patient A needs a crown that costs $1,200. Here’s how the coordination of benefits works:
Primary Plan (Plan 1): Plan 1 covers 80% of the cost, paying 960.240.
Secondary Plan (Plan 2): Plan 2 covers 50% of the remaining balance, paying 120.120.
In this case, having two dental insurances reduces Patient A’s out-of-pocket expense from 240(under Plan1 alone)120.
Common Questions About Dual Dental Insurance
Can I have two dental insurances from the same provider?
Yes, but the coordination of benefits rules will still apply. The two plans must be distinct policies, such as an individual plan and a spouse’s plan.
Will having two dental insurances cover 100% of my costs?
Not always. The combined payments from both plans cannot exceed 100% of the total cost. In some cases, the secondary plan may not pay anything if the primary plan already covers the full cost.
What happens if both plans have different networks?
You may need to choose a dentist who is in-network for both plans to maximize coverage. If the dentists are in different networks, you may face higher out-of-pocket costs.
Can I use dual dental insurance for orthodontic treatment?
Yes, but orthodontic coverage varies by plan. Some plans have lifetime maximums for orthodontics, and the secondary plan may only cover the remaining balance after the primary plan has paid.
Conclusion
Having two dental insurances is allowed and can be a valuable strategy for reducing out-of-pocket costs and maximizing coverage. However, it requires a clear understanding of coordination of benefits, careful management of claims, and regular communication with both insurance providers and your dental office. While dual coverage offers significant advantages, it also comes with complexities and potential drawbacks, such as higher premiums and administrative hassles.
Individuals considering dual dental insurance should carefully evaluate their dental needs, compare the benefits and costs of both plans, and take steps to ensure seamless coordination between the two policies. By doing so, they can make informed decisions about their oral health care and achieve the best possible financial and clinical outcomes. Whether you are covered under one plan or two, working closely with your dentist and insurance providers is key to navigating the process effectively and maintaining a healthy smile.
Related topics:
Does Delta Dental Insurance Cover Dentures?
Does Delta Dental Insurance Cover Cavities?
